A wrong commodity code doesn't usually cause a problem at the border. It causes one later, when HMRC checks your declarations and finds three years of underpaid duty and VAT, or when you discover you've been overpaying all along. This guide explains what HMRC can recover, the penalties, what tribunals have decided, and how to correct a mistake before HMRC finds it.

Key takeaways

  • HMRC can recover underpaid import duty for 3 years after import, and for up to 20 years where an officer believes an offence has been committed
  • It does this with a post-clearance demand note (C18), and interest is charged at Bank Rate plus 3.5% if you pay late
  • Civil penalties run from £250 to £2,500 per error, but a written voluntary disclosure made before HMRC starts enquiries means no penalty
  • Underpaid duty usually means underpaid import VAT too, because VAT is charged on the duty-inclusive value
  • Overpaid duty can be reclaimed within 3 years, and declarations can be amended for up to 3 years after acceptance

If you use the wrong commodity code, one of two things happens. Either you pay too little duty, and HMRC can come back for it with interest and, in some cases, a penalty. Or you pay too much, and unless you notice and claim it back, the money is simply gone. In our audits of new customers, around 2 in 5 tariff codes turn out to be wrong, so most importers are in one position or the other on at least part of their range.

How HMRC finds a wrong code

HMRC checks declarations after goods have been cleared, through audits, risk profiling and reviews of particular products or importers. Because the duty and the measures follow the code, a wrong code can stay invisible for years: the goods clear without fuss, and the problem only shows when HMRC looks.

When HMRC thinks you owe duty, it writes to you first, explaining the decision it intends to make. You have 30 days to respond with information, known as the right to be heard. HMRC then sends its final decision and a post-clearance demand note, the C18, with payment instructions. You can ask for a review or appeal (GOV.UK, customs debt liability).

How a wrong code becomes a C18 in five steps: 1 goods clear on the day of import, 2 HMRC checks through an audit, risk profiling or product review up to 3 years later, 3 right to be heard letter with 30 days to respond, 4 C18 demand for the duty and import VAT, pay within 10 days, 5 pay, review or appeal, with late payment interest at Bank Rate plus 3.5% and a penalty that may follow. Time limit is 3 years from import, or up to 20 years where an HMRC officer believes an offence has been committed
From a code that clears without fuss to a demand for years of duty: how the C18 process runs.

How far back HMRC can go

HMRC must notify you of an import duty debt within 3 years of the day it was incurred, normally the date of the customs entry. For entries made from 1 January 2021, that can extend to 20 years if an HMRC officer believes an offence has been committed.

What it costs: duty, VAT, interest and penalties

HMRC can recover the underpaid duty and import VAT with interest, and can charge a civil penalty of up to £2,500 for each incorrect declaration. Where the error was dishonest, the penalty can reach 100% of the duty evaded.

What you can be chargedHow it works
The underpaid dutyThe difference between the duty you paid and the duty due under the correct code, for every entry in the period
Import VATVAT is charged on the customs value plus duty, so underpaid duty usually means underpaid import VAT. If you used postponed VAT accounting, you correct it on your VAT return
InterestBank Rate plus 3.5% since 6 April 2025, charged if you pay more than 10 days after the C18 is issued
Civil penaltyUp to £2,500 per contravention for providing false information on a declaration, where you knew or ought to have known it was false
Civil evasion penaltyUp to 100% of the duty evaded, but only where the conduct was dishonest; HMRC normally reduces it by up to 80% for co-operation

The civil penalty is set out in Customs Notice 301. HMRC normally sends a warning letter for a first error and charges a penalty if a similar error happens within two years. Penalties usually go up in steps of £250, £500, £1,000, £2,000 and £2,500. An incorrect declaration counts as a serious error when the duty and VAT involved exceed £10,000. Where undeclared duty and VAT exceed £50,000, HMRC may start two steps higher, and above £100,000 it may charge the maximum straight away.

Two points from the notice that importers often miss. First, relying on your customs agent isn't a reasonable excuse if their error caused the problem. Second, acting in good faith, or the duty lost being small, doesn't reduce the penalty.

What tribunals have decided

These UK cases show how demands add up, and how hard it is to overturn them without evidence.

CaseGoodsDemandOutcome
Laurence Supply Co (Leather Goods) Ltd v HMRC [2024] UKFTT 124 (TC)Fashion handbags and purses from ChinaC18 of £603,548.58 (duty £502,956.38 and import VAT £100,592.20), plus a £2,500 penaltyThe company proved one sample was misclassified, but the demand was cut by only £2,064.36 because it couldn't link its samples to the rest of the goods
Build-A-Bear Workshop UK Holdings Ltd v HMRC [2022] EWCA Civ 825Clothes, wigs and shoes for stuffed toysAbout £660,000 at stake on appealThe company lost at every stage: the goods were accessories of stuffed toys at 4.7%, not doll accessories at 0%
Natco Foods Ltd v HMRC [2023] UKFTT 274 (TC)PappadumsC18 of £280,047.41The company had kept using a code from an old ruling after the code ceased to exist. It accepted the code was wrong and won only a lower rate, 14.1% instead of HMRC's 15.7%
WM Morrison Supermarket Ltd v HMRC [2025] UKFTT 1145 (TC)Household aluminium foil£4,758,276.97, cut from £5,073,187.80 because older imports were out of timeA case about origin, not classification: the foil was found to be Chinese, not Thai, so anti-dumping duty applied

You can read each judgment in full on the National Archives' Find Case Law service: Laurence Supply Co v HMRC, Build-A-Bear Workshop v HMRC, Natco Foods v HMRC and WM Morrison Supermarket v HMRC.

The lessons are consistent. The burden is on the importer to show the code is right. A ruling only protects you for the goods, code and period it covers. And the evidence that wins, or saves, a case is the paperwork that ties each product to its code: specifications, samples and the reasoning behind the classification. We covered the Morrisons decision in Morrisons, HMRC and a £4.7m ruling.

The five mistakes behind most wrong codes

When we audit a new customer's codes, the errors usually trace back to the same five habits.

Underestimating how often codes are wrong. Around 2 in 5 codes we check turn out to be incorrect, so a range that has never been reviewed almost certainly has errors in it.

Classifying by hand or with a chatbot. A quick search of the Trade Tariff or a ChatGPT answer can land on a code that looks right without applying the chapter notes and interpretative rules that decide it.

Assuming a code never changes. Products are reformulated, suppliers change materials, and the tariff itself changes. Natco Foods kept using a code that no longer existed.

Thinking low volume means low risk. HMRC can go back three years, so a small error repeated on every shipment adds up.

Leaving it to the broker. A broker often codes from a short description at the point of declaration, and the liability stays with you.

We go through each one, with examples, in five customs classification mistakes that mean fines.

Overpaying is the quieter cost

Wrong codes don't only mean underpaying. A stoneware mug declared under the porcelain code pays 12% instead of 4%. In a worked example, that one line costs an importer about £14,400 a year on £180,000 of imports. Missing a preference under a trade agreement, or paying the residual anti-dumping rate when your exporter has a lower named rate, has the same effect. To see what a code means for your own landed cost, try our import duty calculator.

HMRC won't tell you that you've overpaid. You have to find it and claim it, and the clock is running: repayment claims must be made within 3 years.

How to put a wrong code right

Find out how far the error goes. Identify every product and every entry declared under the wrong code, and work out the duty and VAT effect of each.

If you've underpaid, tell HMRC. After clearance, an underpayment is disclosed through a voluntary clearance amendment (C2001), which leads to a C18 for the extra duty or VAT. If you disclose voluntarily, in writing, before you had reason to think HMRC was enquiring, there's no civil penalty.

If you've overpaid, claim it back. Claim through the Customs Declaration Service or on form C285 within 3 years, with the declaration reference, the commercial invoice and the amount that should have been paid (GOV.UK). VAT-registered businesses correct overpaid import VAT through their VAT return instead.

Amend or correct declarations. CDS import declarations can be amended for up to 3 years after acceptance.

Fix the cause. Correct the code in your product data and ERP so the next shipment goes in right, and record why the new code is correct.

Get certainty where you need it. For products that are genuinely borderline, an Advance Tariff Ruling gives you a legally binding code, generally for three years.

Our commodity code checker guide explains how to check a code properly on the UK Trade Tariff.

How TariffTel helps

Most of the cases above came down to evidence: the importer couldn't show why a product sat under its code. Every classification in TTVerified comes from an expert-built question pathway, is verified by a customs specialist and is logged with its reasoning, so you have an audit trail for each code if HMRC asks. It also shows the duty and preferential rates and flags anti-dumping duty, CBAM and EUDR, so you can see where a code changes what you owe.

If you suspect part of your range is wrong, start with the highest-value and highest-duty lines. The 14-day free trial includes 10 classifications with no card needed, or talk to our Managed Services team about reviewing a whole catalogue. For a single code, TTExplore shows its reasoning with credits from £2 a code.

FAQ

If the wrong code meant you paid too little, HMRC can issue a post-clearance demand (C18) for the underpaid duty and import VAT, usually for up to 3 years of imports, with interest and possibly a civil penalty. If you paid too much, you can reclaim the difference within 3 years.
HMRC can charge a civil penalty of up to £2,500 per contravention for false information on a customs declaration. It normally issues a warning letter first. Where the conduct is dishonest, a civil evasion penalty of up to 100% of the duty evaded can apply.
Three years from the date the debt was incurred, normally the date of import. For entries made from 1 January 2021, that can extend to 20 years if an HMRC officer believes an offence has been committed.
A post-clearance demand note. HMRC issues it to collect customs duty or import VAT that should have been paid at import, after giving you 30 days to respond to its intended decision.
Yes. Under Customs Notice 301, HMRC won't charge a civil penalty if you discover the error and disclose it voluntarily, in writing, before you had reason to believe HMRC was enquiring. You still pay the duty and VAT.
Claim through the Customs Declaration Service or on form C285 within 3 years, with the declaration reference, the commercial invoice and the amount you should have paid.
Usually not on its own. If the broker declares on your behalf under direct representation, you as the importer are liable for the duty. HMRC's penalty guidance also says relying on an agent isn't a reasonable excuse.
Elizabeth Davies

Elizabeth Davies

Head of Customs Compliance & Classification, TariffTel

Elizabeth has more than 15 years’ experience in customs classification, advising UK retailers, manufacturers and food producers on getting commodity codes right and keeping them right. A regular speaker at Food and Drink Federation (FDF) webinars, she leads the team behind TariffTel’s expert-verified classification methodology.

Connect with Elizabeth on LinkedIn